Shannan Gilbert.
I'm in Long Island.
Yeah.
These people are plotting to kill me.
They're gonna kill me.
Please stop it. Please.
No. What are you going to do to me? What are you going to do to me? Stop it!
Suffolk Police 872.
There's a young girl running around here screaming,
and there's some guy trying to follow her.
Suffolk Police. What is the location of your emergency?
Oak Beach Association.
Some woman is knocking at my door.
She says she's in danger.
I'm not letting her in.
What did she look like to you?
She looked, uh, paranoid.
Scared.
So I said, "Let's go home. I'll drive you home."
Let's go back to Manhattan.
Something's going to happen to me.
Stop it, please. Stop it, please.
I think he wanted to push her out, but he grabbed her and she freaked out.
- Please, stop it. No. - Then she ran out.
Who are you?
Somebody after you?
- Are you all right? - I need help.
I saw her behind the bush, so I was like "Oh, I found you."
So I thought everything was okay, but she ran towards another row of houses.
And then, eventually I couldn't find her and I just went home.
I wondered how far off the side of the highway
those four sets of remains were found.
It looks like somebody pulled up on the side of the shoulder,
you know, took the remains,
and maybe walked in a little bit into the brush
and tossed it or laid it down.
We may not be able to determine the cause of death.
The elements have taken their toll,
but we work very closely with our partners.
The head of the FBI office here in Long Island has been up here.
Can you say there's enough similarities that you're certain
the same person murdered these four and dumped them here?
I contacted, like, 18 different precincts,
and got pushed around, pushed around.
Why do you think that was?
It seemed that it wasn't something that they were concerned about.
Is that because they found out about prostitution?
- Escorting? - Yeah, escorting.
Yeah. Maybe.
They didn't think that it was a priority.
I was the last one that Shannan talked to that night,
six hours before she was missing.
We planned for her to come up for my birthday.
She says, "I have to work tonight, Mommy, so I have money to buy you something."
I said, "Look, Shannan, you coming is my gift."
"Don't do it. Just come home and visit me. I love you."
"You don't have to bring me presents. Just come home."
Here's this young woman who's tied
to the cell phone for her business.
Strange thing. She leaves her cell phone behind.
Yeah, no one she knows understands why.
No way of communicating if something happens, you know.
Ten things can happen. Forget about murder.
It doesn't make sense.
I hear a man's voice and I just, like,
my whole body like shut down, like I was just in shock.
"I heard you're a half-breed."
Nobody's got her photograph.
The only thing I can think of,
the only thing I think he might know
is if she had a picture of me on her phone or something.
He was calm. In control.
He was enjoying it, I think. That's the only way I think he'd know.
"Are you going to be a whore like your sister?"
and track the psychopath who's doing this and put an end to it.