New York, Long Island, a series of murders…
Shannan Gilbert is on her way to meet a client.
Megan Waterman disappeared in June 2010.
Are you guys continuing the search, or even more searches going on?
When they went missing, it was just a single…
as they call it, a single prostitute and they just…
And we only had one voice. But now we're…
Right, now we're together.
One, two, three, four, five, six, seven-plus voices.
I am just waiting to be contacted
by authorities to identify any items
that they think may be hers. I hope it's not.
I'm always giving out hope that we'll find her alive.
We had just left here putting crosses in with the four vic-- The four girls.
As we drove by, we'd seen
whatever they call that big machine down there.
And there was somebody cutting brush down,
and we knew they were searching for somebody in there.
We became sick to our stomachs.
Do you think she accidentally drowned in that muck?
Dormer's talking out of his ass.
Shannan was murdered.
Somebody stripped her clothes off
because they did not want Shannan to be found.
Do you still believe it was an accident at this point?
I think it's too coincidental that Shannan was found
where the other victims were found.
There's more that connects Shannan to the murders
than does not connect Shannan to the murders.
Did you hear Danny Culotta ask Michael Quartararo
who killed John Pius?
Uh, he said,
"How could you kill somebody for stealing a minibike?"
"How could someone kill someone for just stealing a minibike?"
And did Michael Quatararo respond to that?
Yes, he did. He said,
"If you were drunk and stoned and you didn't wanna get caught,
you would do the same thing."
And this happened after the investigation was already underway?
Did Burke mention anything about the Gilgo case at all?
Like maybe in a joke or…?
How would you characterize his behavior?